23.976Hz video playing at 24.000?

[CraziFuzzy]

been working on getting reclock set up to work with both my SageTV setup, and PowerDVD (for blu-ray support). I have it switching vid modes properly, wither 59.94 or 23.976 depending on the media, and use pal slowdown if/when i even have a PAL source.

My question comes from what is being displayed/done with 23.976 media (blu-ray, or media file). It is detedting my vid refresh properly at 23.975-23.976. It is detecting the video file as 23.976Hz. It is playing back the file at 24.000 Hz, with the associated resampling to 48048Hz audio. Why is it doing this?

[Jong]

It isn't. Reclock is giving confusing/plain wrong info. Read here:

http://forum.slysoft.com/showthread.php?p=155863#post155863

[CraziFuzzy]

It isn't. Reclock is giving confusing/plain wrong info. Read here:

http://forum.slysoft.com/showthread.php?p=155863#post155863

I figured this was some sort of display bug, and that seems to be the case. I guess I'd be fine if it said 24fps (correct, with rounding), and not 24.000fps (incorrect). Since there haven't been any changes in almost a year it seems, i guess I'll just live with it. It is VERY confusing for newer users though.

EDIT: Perhaps, instead of stating the IDEAL situation (that it would play it at 24.000 fps, with video clock at 24.000Hz), it should instead say:

CINEMA mode: media speed locked to video clock (23.976 fps).

NTSC mode: media speed locked to video clock (59.940/2 = 29.97fps).

PAL mode: media speed locked to video clock (75.000/3 = 25.000fps).

Of course, that all being said, I have since disabled the adaptation anyways, as my set can receive 23.976, 24.000, 25.000, 29.970, and 59.940, so I just use reclock for switching to the proper mode for each media type, and keep it locked on 'Original Speed'. Seems to have stopped a lot of my problems I'd been having.

[leeperry]

well cinema is indeed 24fps, so Reclock does give false informations when it says that it's accelerating 23.976@24.000 when you run 47.952Hz....but what's the deal with "NTSC adaptation: media speed changed to 30.000 fps. Audio resampled at 96096 Hz"

genuine NTSC is 29.97002997002997~ fps, end of story....I run 59.940Hz BTW and I still get that msg :policeman:

and it says "audio -96Hz" :rolleyes:

http://pix.nofrag.com/9/1/d/f974e7c3d4a1c04b1b9ec22c8d8dd.png

[MonkeyBall]

I figured this was some sort of display bug, and that seems to be the case. I guess I'd be fine if it said 24fps (correct, with rounding), and not 24.000fps (incorrect). Since there haven't been any changes in almost a year it seems, i guess I'll just live with it. It is VERY confusing for newer users though.



I agree with your suggestion. The current message is very misleading: it does need to be that accurate especially since no resampling occurs.