Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: Verbatim India vs. Taiwan

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Posts
    12

    Default Verbatim India vs. Taiwan

    Verbatim DVD+R: My local Sams has made in India, Best Buy has made in Taiwan. Is one preferrable over the other, as far as quality goes? I can't find Singapore made anywhere.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Posts
    30,519

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by nacholibre View Post
    Verbatim DVD+R: My local Sams has made in India, Best Buy has made in Taiwan. Is one preferrable over the other, as far as quality goes?
    That's debatable. If they're made in Taiwan, they are made by CMC or Prodisc. If they're made in India, they're made by Moser Baer. When the discs are being made for Verbatim, those disc are all supposed to be produced to Verbatim's high standards. We all know that what's supposed to happen doesn't always occur.

    Of these, I tend to prefer the ones made by CMC, but there have been some really (and I mean really) poorly produced CMC-made Verbatims.
    Last edited by Webslinger; 10th July 2009 at 23:14.
    My responses 1) presume you own the original retail disc you are attempting to backup, 2) tend to represent myself only, and 3) do not necessarily represent the views of SlySoft nor its developers. I do not work for SlySoft.

    Please post all technical support questions on the forums instead of private messaging me. Technical support requests sent to me will be ignored. Private message me only for moderation issues, please. Thank you.

    Please read the SlySoft Forum Etiquette before posting.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    in the fox-hole
    Posts
    1,201

    Default

    My DVD-R from Verbatim, the ones I just bought are made in "UAE" and the older ones in "Taiwan" both have the media code: [DVD-R:MCC 03RG20]

    Are these good Verbatim ones?

    Thank you!
    BurnerHEAD
    OPTIARC BD ROM BC-5500S (Notebook); Pioneer BDR-206D and Pioneer DVR-S18L (PC); Panasonic Bluray Recorder DMR-BS785, WDTV Live Hub and MyBook Live 3TB (TV)
    German ClownBD Thread

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Posts
    30,519

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BurnerHEAD View Post
    My DVD-R from Verbatim, the ones I just bought are made in "UAE"
    Yeah, those are made by Falcon Technologies International (FTI). Some people are getting excellent results from those. But there's not enough feedback yet to form a solid opinion.

    Are these good Verbatim ones?
    They can be.
    My responses 1) presume you own the original retail disc you are attempting to backup, 2) tend to represent myself only, and 3) do not necessarily represent the views of SlySoft nor its developers. I do not work for SlySoft.

    Please post all technical support questions on the forums instead of private messaging me. Technical support requests sent to me will be ignored. Private message me only for moderation issues, please. Thank you.

    Please read the SlySoft Forum Etiquette before posting.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    in the fox-hole
    Posts
    1,201

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Webslinger View Post
    Yeah, those are made by Falcon Technologies International (FTI). Some people are getting excellent results from those. But there's not enough feedback yet to form a solid opinion.

    They can be.
    I have never used any other ones, because I liked my results. This is also true, because I never burn faster than 4x, or sometimes 8x.

    I have another question about Double-Layer ones from Verbatim:

    DVD+R DLs = Verbatim made in Singapore (preferably not India) and MAM-A 8x
    DVD-R DLs = none (useless format)
    why is DVD-R DL a useless format?

    General question about DVD-R and DVD DL from Verbatim:
    - Are the ones from Taiwan better than those from India?

    - What is special about Singapore made ones?

    Thanks!
    BurnerHEAD
    OPTIARC BD ROM BC-5500S (Notebook); Pioneer BDR-206D and Pioneer DVR-S18L (PC); Panasonic Bluray Recorder DMR-BS785, WDTV Live Hub and MyBook Live 3TB (TV)
    German ClownBD Thread

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Posts
    30,519

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BurnerHEAD View Post

    why is DVD-R DL a useless format?
    The layer break position is fixed (mostly)


    Are the ones from Taiwan better than those from India?
    If they are made in Taiwan they are either made by Prodisc or CMC and sold under Verbatim's label.

    If they are made in India, they are made by Moser Baer and sold under Verbatim's label.

    In my experience CMC produced Verbatim's tend to be better than the others you just mentioned. However, CMC has produced some horrible stuff that's been sold under Verbatim's label in the past.

    Some people like Moser Baer media that's sold under Vebatim's label. I don't.

    What is special about Singapore made ones?
    Verbatim is a subsidiary of Mitsubishi Chemical Corporation. Mitsubishi's plant is/was in Singapore. Verbatim made in Singapore is "real" Verbatim. And "real" Verbatim is more consistent in quality.

    Another thing to note is that in the words "Datalife Plus", the "Plus" denotes Verbatim's higher end line (but that line is mostly outsourced anyway).
    My responses 1) presume you own the original retail disc you are attempting to backup, 2) tend to represent myself only, and 3) do not necessarily represent the views of SlySoft nor its developers. I do not work for SlySoft.

    Please post all technical support questions on the forums instead of private messaging me. Technical support requests sent to me will be ignored. Private message me only for moderation issues, please. Thank you.

    Please read the SlySoft Forum Etiquette before posting.

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    in the fox-hole
    Posts
    1,201

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Webslinger View Post
    The layer break position is fixed (mostly)
    hmm, okay. But how can that be a problem?

    I prefer DVD-R over DVD+R, because DVD-R runs in more DVD players, so logically I would use DVD-R DL...



    If they are made in Taiwan they are either made by Prodisc or CMC and sold under Verbatim's label.

    If they are made in India, they are made by Moser Baer and sold under Verbatim's label.

    In my experience CMC produced Verbatim's tend to be better than the others you just mentioned. However, CMC has produced some horrible stuff that's been sold under Verbatim's label in the past.

    Some people like Moser Baer media that's sold under Vebatim's label. I don't.
    How can I get CMC stuff here in Europe?

    How can the quality of a DVD blank be measured?



    Verbatim is a subsidiary of Mitsubishi Chemical Corporation. Mitsubishi's plant is/was in Singapore. Verbatim made in Singapore is "real" Verbatim. And "real" Verbatim is more consistent in quality.

    Another thing to note is that in the words "Datalife Plus", the "Plus" denotes Verbatim's higher end line (but that line is mostly outsourced anyway).
    So, having MCC blanks is a good thing?

    Well, is "Datalife Plus" something US like?

    in terms of DVD blanks I can only buy "Extra Protection" and "AZO", where AZO is the better quality.


    Thank you!
    BurnerHEAD
    OPTIARC BD ROM BC-5500S (Notebook); Pioneer BDR-206D and Pioneer DVR-S18L (PC); Panasonic Bluray Recorder DMR-BS785, WDTV Live Hub and MyBook Live 3TB (TV)
    German ClownBD Thread

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Posts
    30,519

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BurnerHEAD View Post
    hmm, okay. But how can that be a problem?
    You can't retain the original layer break position.

    I prefer DVD-R over DVD+R, because DVD-R runs in more DVD players
    No. That's complete nonsense. Once you've changed booktype to "dvd-rom", dvd+r plays on all players.

    The only problems that arise in compatibility with playback at that point are typically due to a lower reflectivity depending on the reflective layer used in the blank disc.

    In fact, having booktype changed to "dvd-rom" can help to ensure compatibility, especially if players are checking for media type (used to be a common check with some game protections).

    I don't buy dvd-r.



    How can I get CMC stuff here in Europe?
    You may already if your Verbatim is made in Taiwan. You would need batch codes/serial codes (often found printed on the inner plastic hub of the blank disc). This thread is old, but it gives you an idea of what to look for: http://club.cdfreaks.com/f33/identif...im-16x-175056/




    How can the quality of a DVD blank be measured?
    Longevity testing (exposure to different environments including heat and humidity)

    and

    PI/PO/jitter testing (over a wide variety of burners) is common online

    and

    CATS testing

    I also like looking at C't test results (typically shows how various burners do with certain types of blank media): http://www.cdrlabs.com/forums/test-r...rs-t13405.html




    So, having MCC blanks is a good thing?
    Well a lot of companies that produce blanks for Verbatim use the MCC media code. So MCC, in of itself, may not mean much. MCC and being made in Singapore are good things.


    Well, is "Datalife Plus" something US like?
    It has been mostly phased out in Europe. Datalife Plus is still found in the U.S. and Canada.


    in terms of DVD blanks I can only buy "Extra Protection" and "AZO", where AZO is the better quality.
    That's misleading. In the past Super Azo may have been better. That's a tough call lately. "Extra Protection" refers to the top layer of the disc. It's a harder top coating, which offers more scratch resistance and protection. These discs are produced by various manufacturers, and so, you may get different results. "Azo Crystal" is even better than "Extra Protection". "Crystal" is even more resistant. Keep in mind that some "Extra Protection" discs that were made in Japan by Taiyo Yuden were excellent.

    Typically Verbatim discs made in Japan are produced by Taiyo Yuden.
    Last edited by Webslinger; 11th December 2009 at 18:03.
    My responses 1) presume you own the original retail disc you are attempting to backup, 2) tend to represent myself only, and 3) do not necessarily represent the views of SlySoft nor its developers. I do not work for SlySoft.

    Please post all technical support questions on the forums instead of private messaging me. Technical support requests sent to me will be ignored. Private message me only for moderation issues, please. Thank you.

    Please read the SlySoft Forum Etiquette before posting.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Posts
    12,212

    Default

    It still surprises me when I people say DVD-R is more compatible. That is a fallacy that people keep on perpetuating. As Webslinger noted, a DVD+R disc booktyped to DVD-ROM is seen exactly the same as a commercially pressed DVD-ROM disc. How can DVD-R be more compatible than that? In technical terms DVD+R is better than DVD-R, as well.
    DrinkLyeAndDie

    • All users agreed to follow forum rules when they registered and are expected to abide by them. Ignorance is not an excuse.
    • I neither represent nor am I employed by SlySoft or its developers. My responses do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of SlySoft or its employees.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    in the fox-hole
    Posts
    1,201

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by DrinkLyeAndDie View Post
    It still surprises me when I people say DVD-R is more compatible. That is a fallacy that people keep on perpetuating. As Webslinger noted, a DVD+R disc booktyped to DVD-ROM is seen exactly the same as a commercially pressed DVD-ROM disc. How can DVD-R be more compatible than that? In technical terms DVD+R is better than DVD-R, as well.
    Well, that's what I heard. DVD-R doesn't need to be booktyped and because it's the official format, plays in all standalone players.

    Best Regards,
    BurnerHEAD

    I guess I will order some DVD+R DL from Verbatim and see how that goes.
    OPTIARC BD ROM BC-5500S (Notebook); Pioneer BDR-206D and Pioneer DVR-S18L (PC); Panasonic Bluray Recorder DMR-BS785, WDTV Live Hub and MyBook Live 3TB (TV)
    German ClownBD Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •